Diagnosing Employer Needs

Employer Impact

Introduction

Apprenticeships experts Bally Bhogal of LX Group Ltd and Natalie Rae of Natalie Rae Consultancy Ltd lead and facilitate the Apprenticeship Accelerator programme – a groundbreaking ‘peer-to-peer’ learning network for apprenticeship training providers.  The lessons learned from each of the sessions delivered have been summarised into a blog series.  This article focusses on why diagnosing employer and line manager needs is so critical to apprenticeship delivery and apprentice development.

 

The Challenge:             Diagnosing Employer Needs Effectively

In this blog, we review the outcomes of the Apprenticeship Accelerator ‘peer-learning’ network session on how to diagnose employer and line manager needs effectively for the purpose of delivering educational services, such as apprenticeship programmes.  To be an apprentice, the learner must be employed (under a contract of employment) and have a ‘supervisor’ or ‘mentor’ or ‘line manager’ at work to support the development process of the apprentice. To provide an exceptional learning and work experience, it is critical to diagnose employer and line manager needs and tailor the apprenticeship programme to fit all parties. In this session, we explored how to effectively and confidently diagnose employer needs and what to do with the information once collated via:

  • Reviewing the challenges that providers face when diagnosing employer needs
  • Exploring a whole-organisational approach to employer needs diagnosis by apprenticeship training providers
  • Understanding the everyday challenges that employers and line managers face within their own organisations

Employers are critical to apprenticeships for providing real work environments in which learning takes place to develop trainees into key roles for the future.  Employers invest time, human and financial resource into apprenticeship schemes with a view to building capacity and capability to future-proof their businesses – hence programmes must be fit for purpose, progressive and productive for employers to realise the true benefits of apprenticeships.

As, apprenticeships provide the perfect opportunity (and balance) to develop trainees academically, as well as practically on-the-job and off-the-job – it requires all parties to work together to create a programme that blends well to deliver a superior practical learning experience, rigorous academic output and progressive career outcomes.

15 x CHALLENGES OF DIAGNOSING EMPLOYER NEEDS

Out of the 15 challenges and barriers often faced by apprenticeship training providers when diagnosing employer training or skills needs, some examples are provided below – please contact the Apprenticeship Accelerator team for a full list:

  1. No standardised diagnostic framework
  2. Too target-focused, not solution-focused
  3. Fragmented information flow
  4. No centralised employer record
  5. Lacking cross-organisational alignment for employer impact

 

THE STRATEGIC LEVERS OF EMPLOYER ENGAGEMENT & NEEDS DIAGNOSIS

It is essential for providers to have a strategic vision and a well-mapped approach to working with employers if high-quality training services and learning experiences are to be delivered. This means aligning strategic vision with operational activities to deliver impactful, progressive and value-for-money programmes, that deliver results for employers.

It can be challenging for apprenticeship training providers to cater to employer needs if/where there is a lack of agility, mobility and trapped potential within their organisations. Below are some strategies on how to release employer engagement potential within a provider organisation at different levels:

  1. STRATEGIC LEADERSHIP & GOVERNANCE LEVEL

AIM: Cross-organisational approach to employer needs through direction, decision making and accountability

  • Organisational Strategy – Create vision, direction and a connected organisation with shared roles and responsibility for employer engagement
  • Employer, Partnerships and Engagement and Policy – Include decision making structures andreporting lines to ensure strategy flows into action on the ground

 

  • Marketing and Communications – Inform and connect internal marketing teams with employer engagement, skills identification and programme delivery teams

 

  1. SYSTEMS, OPERATIONS & PROCESSES

AIM: Evaluate how the organisation actually delivers its work and whether it is efficient, compliant, connected and scalable

  • Single organisational needs matrix for employers – Use the CRM to go beyond the ‘sale’ – include complaints, queries and skills needs analysis data

 

  • Walk throughs – To see how policies translate into day-to-day activity and links to quality assurance activity

 

  • Structured needs templates / Skills annual audit – Provide a skills review service and supporting ongoing / informal activity with standardised questioning frameworks

 

  1. PEOPLE & PRACTICE

AIM: Understand internal workforce capability, culture and practice that enables or hinders performance.

  • Staff skills gap analysis – Check if all employees are aware of the processes and expectations of employer engagement, in relation to their own roles and responsibilities
  • Training and development – Deliver cross-organisational understanding of what effective ‘skills identification’ means, how employer priorities should be factored and processes for communicating opportunities
  • ‘Triangulated Approach’ – Combine real-time employer feedback, apprentice performance data and market research analysis for accurate diagnosis and needs assessment.
  1. CUSTOMERS & CONSUMERS

AIM: Understand how the organisation understands, serves and grows its customer base.

  • Service-Quality alignment – Check whether what is promised in strategy is what is experienced in reality
  • Customer journey mapping – See where customers experience challenges, friction and value in the end-to-end process – clear identification of training needs
  • Stakeholders and market intelligence – Seek every opportunity to recognise, capture and share insights

A WHOLE-ORGANISATIONAL APPROACH TO EMPLOYER NEEDS DIAGNOSIS

To provide a responsive service to employers, apprenticeship training providers must understand the pain points, challenges, issues and concerns of employers. This can includefor example, Industry Advancements (e.g. New Scope, Change in Direction, Change in Strategy, Change Requests, New Projects, Technological Advancements, etc.); New Product Development or Design (New Products/Services, New Processes & Procedures, Pilot Programmes and Test Phases, etc.); Supply of Labour (e.g. New Jobs & Skills, New Technologies, New Equipment, New Products, Reskilling/Upskilling Requests, Redesign/Revamp, etc.), Labour & Skills Supply (Recruitment & Selection, Initial Screenings, Retention, Line Manager Requirements, Succession Planning, etc.).   Some further examples of factors that can drive demand for training include:

  • Sector or Industrial Changes
  • Political Changes
  • Economic Climate or Trading Conditions
  • Product or Service Demand
  • Recruitment Challenges

10 x STEPS FOR DIAGNOSING EMPLOYER NEEDS

To diagnose employer needs effectively, apprenticeship training providers must obtain a deep insight of how the employer business operates and the key challenges it faces. They can do this in 10 steps – the first 4 are provided below (a full list is available from the Apprenticeship Accelerator team – please get in touch):

  • Find out what the business does, what products or services it sells and what the business vision is for the next 3-5 years;
  • Understand how departments are structured to create the full organisational chart;
  • Explore what key functions or departments exist and how people, roles, objectives and targets of each are planned;
  • Identify what the key issues of the business are, including pain points, concerns, problems, risks, challenges and issues…

When this information is effectively collated, then providers can move to the analysis phase and creating solutions by way of a Workforce Development or Growth Plan.  Exploring which (current) training programmes can be allocated – with or without funding – and/or new programmes can be designed or developed to support the employer to progress from their current position is the function of a ‘critical’ workforce development partner.  All of the knowledge received from the employer should be leveraged to:

  1. Inform product development and curriculum updates within provider settings
  2. Improve programme (training and content) relatability and currency
  3. Drive regular CPD sector updates for apprenticeship training and support staff

 

Ideal Skills of Business Development Managers and/or Employer Engagement staff

People buy from people they trust. Building trust requires skillful development of approaches to engage employers and line managers into deep and meaningful conversations that inspire confidence and deliver value. Some ideal skillsets and competencies of business development or employer engagement managers are listed below;

  • Excellent business acumen
  • A genuine interest in ‘business’ and how it works
  • Understanding of pressures/targets of line managers
  • Can provide a range of options by working with curriculum teams and knows the limitations of each solution
  • Can obtain commitments using success stories/previous examples

 

Actions that training providers can take to improve employer needs diagnosis and tailoring of training solutions to meet current and future needs include, for example:

  1. Review who your target employers are and how you communicate with them
  2. Review your employer needs diagnostic methodology – is it ‘fit for purpose?’
  3. Use every touch point to demonstrate your expertise, authority and impact
  4. Use diagnostic information to update curricula in order to remain current/ahead of industry standards
  5. Train staff on industry developments to cultivate a culture of learning and innovation aligned to industry needs

 

Key Outcomes and Takeaways of the Collaborative Problem-Solving Approach

“After today’s training we will look at ways to re-introduce our Employer Forums in the industry sectors that we have struggled to engage with in the past.”

Employer Engagement & Partnerships Consultant, FE Consultant

 

“We need more data accuracy (CRM) and company-wide knowledge and understanding as to the ways of working with employers as per our vision”

Sales & Growth Lead, ITP

 

“The training session gave me the opportunity to reflect on our processes, particularly how we gather and use data to inform decision-making. As a result, we are planning to add a skills audit assessment to our CRM, along with an annual review date to ensure the information remains up to date. We also identified the need to review our repeat and new business strategy with a stronger focus on the customer journey, paying attention to pinch points and areas for improvement!”

Head of Employer Engagement, ITP

 

Authors: B.Bhogal, LX Group Ltd and Natalie Rae, Natalie Rae Consultancy Ltd (24/08/26)

Share the Post:

You may also like

Related Posts