The Apprenticeships Subcontracting Standard is the Education Skills Funding Agency’s (ESFA) newly established framework of key processes and activities for lead providers to implement and follow if/where £100,000 or more of delivery is subcontracted, across all ESFA funding streams. The Subcontracting Standard has 10 sections within it, each comprising of a set of individual criteria that must be complied with, as detailed below:
- Pre-award activities
- Contract award and management
- People
- Administration
- Managing relationships
- Managing performance
- Payments and incentives
- Risk management
- Contract development and/or termination
- Provider development
Preparing for the Subcontracting Standard can seem daunting at first, however the full framework and corresponding list of criteria to comply with are available for review at the link below, which is extremely useful for any lead provider, as part of the preparation activities:
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/esfa-subcontracting-standard/esfa-subcontracting-standard
There are significant changes from the Subcontractor Assurance Controls Audit to the Subcontracting Standard. Some examples include:
What makes subcontracting within apprenticeships or funded learning programs high risk? Subcontracting in itself is not high risk; what makes it risky is not understanding the risks associated with subcontracting and not taking action to limit them. Subcontracting within post-16 education programmes is not a new phenomenon – for decades now the Education Skills Funding Agency (ESFA) has allowed training providers (e.g. colleges of further education, private training providers, employers, local authorities and more recently universities) to subcontract training delivery to other providers in order to deliver the Government’s vision and targets for education. It’s fair to say that the parameters around subcontracting were not as prescribed or as defined as what they are today; in current times there is far more management control and rigour around subcontracting than before by the ESFA.
Historical events have forced the hand of the Government to rein subcontracting in. With a string of high-profile failures linked to (for example) mis-management of funding within education, a lack of governance and oversight of subcontractors and poor value for money, the ESFA finally concluded that no more than 25% of contract values will be permitted to be subcontracted by lead providers from academic year 22-23, unless special exemption was otherwise provided or if the lead provider is a local authority – for which 100% subcontracting is permissible.
Unfortunately, subcontracting has a bad name within education and it operates under its very own ‘black cloud’ of compliance requirements, funding rules and regulations. It is not easy, however it has its uses. The purpose is clear and officially published by the ESFA; the education rationale (for subcontracting) meets one or more of the following aims:
- enhances the opportunities available for learners
- fills gaps in niche or expert provision or provides better access to training facilities
- supports better geographical access for learners
- offers an entry point for disadvantaged groups; or
- gives consideration of the impact on individuals with shared protected characteristics, where there might otherwise be gaps.
The Pitfalls of Apprenticeship Subcontracting
Meeting one or more of these aims is a clear goal for the ESFA and subcontracting must help to achieve this. A strong vision for education, a clear rationale for subcontracting and a highly effective strategy to deliver educational results would be desirable to ensure that subcontracting does not distract funding away from the delivery of front-line training and/or assessment services. Sadly, historical events have proven that management controls have either not been in place or have been ineffective to manage subcontracted delivery with providers being subject to repayment of funding received, filing for bankruptcy, being involved in litigation proceedings for fraud and deception, as examples. For these reasons, the ESFA take a cautious and controlled approach to subcontracting within education.
Below are five scenarios that we have used to help and describe where and how subcontracting can go wrong – learn these apprenticeship subcontracting pitfalls so that you can avoid them:
- Poor Subcontracting Rationale
Developing a subcontracting rationale is a fairly recent development (a requirement since the apprenticeship reforms in 2017). Lead providers are now expected to state explicitly within a written statement why they are subcontracting and how it forms part of their overall strategy to deliver educational services to their target market, as per their niche and area(s) of expertise. This helps to align subcontracting with the overall vision for training and helps to form a strong basis for partnership working with subcontracted providers. Often, a weak vision and strategy for training can lead to all parties ‘not being on the same page’ hence it is hugely important as part of the scene-setting that all parties are clear on the vision, the reason for subcontracting and the results to be achieved collaboratively.
- Weak Policies & Processes
Often, lead providers have weak policies and processes in place to manage external delivery in its entirety, including for example, written policies that are clear and enforced for the purpose of achieving maximum benefit for learners. Onboarding providers to new systems and paperwork to evidence training and assessment delivered can be ‘hit and miss,’ as well as outlining processes for invoicing and payments. Weaknesses within policies and processes can result in inadequate due diligence prior to contract, or poor performance management ‘in-contract’, or lack of improvement during delivery as a result of poor quality assurance processes, for example.
- Compliance Issues
Compliance is a significant area of risk for the ESFA especially when it comes to subcontracting. More often than not, a lack of understanding around the funding rules and contract requirements of the ESFA, as well as the agreed and contracted deliverables between lead and subcontractor contribute significantly to subcontracting failure. Likely causes may be linked to unskilled staff managing subcontracted relationships or a lack of training and CPD for staff managing suppliers or simply ‘low to no’ understanding of the ESFA’s funding rules. Whatever the cause, the consequences can be severe, for example clawback of funding, termination of contracts (depending on the severity of non-compliance) and/or removal from the Register of Apprenticeship Training Providers (RoATP).
- Financial Payments & Reporting
Ensuring that subcontractors are managed and monitored for the work they complete and that there is evidence in place to support the activities completed prior to payment is crucial. As logical as it sounds, there have been cases in which suppliers were paid prior to contracted work being completed or delivered resulting in the same serious consequences as described in Point 3 above. Too much leniency and little control has led to lead providers exposing themselves to financial risk unnecessarily as discovered during random audits as carried out by the commissioners of funding (ESFA).
- Governance & Accountability
The responsibility for all funded learning delivery sits with the executive team. The governance team must ensure that funding is properly managed, that the public purse is protected from mis-use or mis-handling of funds, including fraud, deception and negligence, as well as to ensure that value for money is achieved. Where governance teams are ineffective in executing their roles effectively, it is often due to a lack of knowledge around what they need to review, how often and why; not requesting the right or enough information for scrutiny to analyse performance and a lack of action planning as a result. A lot of the problems with subcontracting falls on the shoulders of the top team as a result.
The Subcontracting Standard helps to create some consistency around the expectations of what lead providers need to do to procure, manage, monitor, govern and develop subcontractors to deliver funded learning and assessment activities to the value of £100,000 or more across for example, apprenticeships, Adult Education Budget (AEB), study programmes and/or traineeships. Any new providers considering subcontracting should carefully consider the contents of the link provided below to understand the requirements of the ESFA in more detail prior to committing; it is equally useful for all those providers either leading or subcontracting as part of preparing for external assessment against the Standard:
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/esfa-subcontracting-standard
For more information on the Subcontracting Standard and how it applies to your organisation (lead providers and/or subcontractors), contact Bally Bhogal at LX Group on 07399 426907 or by email at bally@lxgroup.ltd
For more information on Apprenticeships Subcontracting, click here


