As soon as I saw the title of this workshop at an Apprenticeship industry event, I rushed to sign up! Having worked in the funded-learning sector for 20 years, the thought of the Education Skills Funding Agency (ESFA) simplifying the apprenticeship delivery system through consultation with suppliers and providers already in the marketplace, was clearly something not to be missed. For those who are somewhat unfamiliar with the apprenticeship delivery marketplace place it can be a minefield at the best of times, hence here are ten key points to bring the uninitiated up to speed:
- Your organisation must be registered on the Register of Apprenticeship Training Providers (RoATP) operated by the ESFA to deliver apprenticeships;
- There is no charge for applying to the RoATP; only one attempt per year is permissible and only the ESFA can grant you access to apply – provided there is a strong case for another provider to join the list;
- Apprenticeship Training Providers are required to sign up to a number of Government platforms and portals to deliver funded-learning programmes; these help the ESFA to manage and monitor apprenticeship performance and delivery;
- There are rules for delivering apprenticeships – a whopping 150 pages of them! These must be adhered to throughout the design, delivery, management and monitoring processes by all apprenticeship training providers;
- The Apprenticeship Service is the ESFA’s front-end platform that allows training providers and employers to transact throughout the apprenticeship delivery service;
- The Apprenticeship Service allows new employer accounts to be created, funding for apprenticeships to be reserved and apprentices to be sourced via the ‘Recruit an Apprentice’ module within the system;
- The Apprenticeship Service allows financial transactions to flow under the guardianship of the ESFA in the background;
- When delivering funded-learning there is always a requirement to manage the ‘public purse’ ethically, hence providers are also subject to impromptu audits by the ESFA as part of their assurance programme;
- Subcontracting training provision is permissible within apprenticeships – it is simply subject to its own set of funding rules (…also embedded within the 150 pages as aforementioned);
- When subcontracting apprenticeship delivery, the lead provider must additionally adhere to the Subcontracting Standard framework as implemented by the ESFA in funding year 22-23.
This list is not exhaustive, hence why the high interest levels (and attendance) at the ESFA conference in December 2022. We learnt that “61% of providers on the RoATP are ITPs [Independent Training Providers], 14% are Employers 11% are FE Colleges, 6% are HEPs [Higher Education Providers].” Admittedly, I was rather surprised that the number of employers delivering their own apprenticeships exceeds the number of FE Colleges doing the same, however it was also satisfying to know that employers are grasping the nettle to deliver a tailored and personal apprenticeship experience for their respective brands.
“61% of providers on the RoATP are ITPs, 14% are Employers 11% are FE Colleges, 6% are HEPs.”
Education Skills Funding Agency (ESFA)
I noted with interest that there is no plan by the ESFA to open the registration process, other than on a ‘needs-basis’ only, which is prudent given that the ‘open floodgates’ approach in 2017-2018 failed from a quality perspective. However, the downside of the current approach could be that potentially, great-quality providers may not get an opportunity to apply due to over-supply against demand which is an aspect tightly controlled by the ESFA. The ESFA also closely monitors the performance of apprenticeship training providers through their recently implemented Provider Accountability Framework, which monitors key metrics such as apprenticeship achievement, employer and learner feedback and timely achievement as examples.
Linked to this is the ESFA’s vast audit and assurance programme which covers both pre-16 and post-16 educational delivery and is ultimately accountable to the National Audit Office and HM Treasury. It is an undertaking on a colossal scale with the ESFA responsible for managing proper and legitimate use of the public purse allocated to schools, colleges, employers, private organisations, etc. for delivering education, including apprenticeships. It did not go unnoticed that across the 1300+ independent training providers through which £1.9bn funding flowed, contracts ranged from a mere £166 to a staggering £60m. Hence why the audit and assurance team is intent on ensuring that:
“Provider controls audits help new providers develop systems and controls to ensure their ILR data (and evidence) complies with funding rules.”
Education Skills Funding Agency (ESFA)
There is still much work to be done by way of simplifying the funding rules for delivery. Providers are still crying out for duplication and repetition within and across Funding Rule documents to be diminished. It appears that an “ongoing internal review of every rule line by line to determine if it is still required” is still being conducted by the ESFA with “engagement with external stakeholders inc. UVAC, AOC, AELP and FSB to gather views about what rules need to change.” Whilst this is encouraging, the results of the review seem a long way off, although we know of some of the areas of compliance that are still causing concerns for the ESFA, for example:
- Evidence of the start of learning;
- Off the job training – if the completion condition is not met, the whole apprenticeship for that learner is ineligible for funding;
- Apprenticeship agreement and commitment statement/training plan – must be two separate documents;
- Ineligible costs;
- Payment of employer contributions (co-funding);
- End dates should be last day of learning activity for withdrawals;
- Recognition of prior attainment and English and Maths must be evidenced in line with the funding rule requirements and retained in the evidence pack
There is a long way to go to streamline the apprenticeship system and the complexities created by the ESFA quite possibly in direct response to rogue and unscrupulous providers. However, providers with good morals and great intent have also got caught up in the spider web of mechanics that is apprenticeship delivery. This is not to say however that the ‘open-door’ conversation and style approach by the ESFA is not welcome; on the contrary it is a welcome breath of fresh air by all providers and suppliers that operate within the sector, as it is universally agreed that simplification is needed, wanted and is most definitely overdue.
For more information on apprenticeships and how to delivery apprenticeship training, contact Bally Bhogal at LX Group on 07399 426907 or by email at bally@lxgroup.ltd
Useful links below:
https://www.gov.uk/guidance/apprenticeship-funding-rules
https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/apprenticeship-training-provider-accountability-framework
https://www.gov.uk/guidance/register-of-apprenticeship-training-providers


