Lack of Diversity Within FE Boards

The (Unsurprising) Lack of Diversity Within FE Leadership 

The 19th November 2021 edition of FE Week (Edition 370) carries a revealing article on a recent survey by the Association of Colleges which has concluded (surprise, surprise) that college boards and leadership teams need to be much more diverse.  The research found that more than 50% of FE college boards have no Black members, while over a third have no Asian members. Nearly 50% have 10 or more male members but only 7% have 10 or more female members.  63% have no members declaring a physical disability and less than 1% have a member who identifies as non-heterosexual or gender-reassigned.

 

Are these findings depressing? Yes. Are they surprising? Not at all! Every so often we get reminded about the lack of diversity within the FE sector at leadership and governance level and as usual, very little changes. I have to ask the question; does anyone actually care about diversity on these boards enough to do something about it – or is it simply not up for discussion?

 

Sadly, this is just yet more evidence of the lack of vision, lack of forward-thinking and unwillingness to take decisive action that seems to plague our industry. Having worked in the Apprenticeships and work-based learning space for nearly 20 years, the sector’s endemic inability to embrace change has long been a source of intense frustration.  As a woman of colour and leader of an organisation which is trying to deliver change and improved standards to Apprenticeships practitioners, the concept of diversity infuses every aspect of both my professional outlook and the work that we do as an organisation.  But, ironically for an industry which is focused on training and education, even in the post-George Floyd and #MeToo era many organisations seem unwilling or unable to learn some relatively fundamental lessons. This is all the more surprising, given the demographic make-up of the sector’s client base; college student populations, for example, are the most diverse in the country.

 

So how do we accelerate change? My co-director, Michael Barrows, who is also Chair of the National Black Governors Network, believes that its simply a question of corporate mindset.  “Leaders create the mindset of the organisation – and organisations should also be a reflection of their client bases and the societies they operate in,” he says. “Diversity and inclusion shouldn’t now be a trendy discussion topic, it should be a fundamental part of corporate DNA – ‘who we are,’ not ‘what we do.’  Its relatively simple for organisations to take steps to achieve this by, for example, adopting the RACE Code Quality Mark. But you can only solve a problem by recognising that you have one and its quite damning that 70% of the governance professionals questioned in the survey described their boards as diverse.”

 

Governors should be more than adept by now at analysing equality and diversity data within the student population, however it remains questionable (judging by the statistics on this article) if the same scrutiny is applied to the composition of the leadership, management and governance teams and the overall staff base.  What deliberate efforts are made to ensure that individuals from diverse backgrounds are developed into higher level roles through training, secondments, enrichment projects, promotional opportunities and through fair recruitment/selection policies?  What actions are taken to identify and remove (conscious or unconscious) bias in order to create a level playing field for all? What exactly is the impact of a diverse board on learners and the learning experience?

 

There is still so much to be done…

 


Bally Bhogal is Managing Director of LX Group Ltd, a niche provider of educational consultancy services, online training and coaching around apprenticeship design, delivery, management and governance.    Contact Bally at: bally@lxgroup.ltd, or via LinkedIn.

LX Group are experts in apprenticeships.  We help employers and businesses from any industry, as well as commercial training organisations to become apprenticeship training providers. Our products and services are based on a single framework for implementing the operations required to design, deliver and manage apprenticeships (Spectrum-39™) as an apprenticeship training provider.

If you are looking to become a provider of apprenticeship training and would like to confidentially discuss any of your challenges, issues or concerns, please email us at info@lxgroup.ltd and we will contact you to arrange a mutually convenient appointment.

 

Share the Post:

You may also like

Related Posts