The Scandal of Wasted Funding in the FE Sector

The ESFA has just published its annual accounts for 2020-21 – and it makes for depressing reading! Among the “lowlights” are 48 cases of “cash losses” by colleges and ITPs totalling over £9m in losses; 24 overpayment claims waived or abandoned, totalling over £33m; and the cost of putting a 2-college group through administration likely to exceed £60m.

 

You don’t have to be an accountant to work out that these (eyewatering) figures are seriously damning for the Education sector. Ok, they include schools and academies (which I cannot speak for), however with familiar references to Independent Training Providers and FE colleges (both of whom deliver a huge range of vocational provision between them) it is seriously concerning that practices have not improved to oversee and manage the public purse within these types of institutions.

 

Many of us complain that this sector is too highly regulated – there is no shortage of funding rules, contracts, clauses, guidance documents, declaration requirements, digital signatures, vetting processes, health-checks, audits, meetings, reviews and ‘interventions’ (all designed to manage, monitor and protect the public purse). Yet despite all these checks and balances being in place, prudent management of funding continues to be a major issue.  Despite the many portals, systems, technologies and frameworks, it seems that epic failures like the afore-mentioned will continue to plague this sector.

 

And exactly what are the reasons for these organisations – many of them sizeable – going bust? Ran out of cash? Financial lag? Not enough learners? Risky or bad subcontracting? Unaware of contractual obligations or funding rules? Ghost learners? Oversights by staff? Inefficient systems or processes? Lack of governance and scrutiny? You can only fully scrutinise something when you are fully aware of its mechanics and wiring, otherwise you are shooting in the dark. And that’s the inconvenient truth; very often it’s the result of very poor leadership by people who don’t fully understand the rules – or deliberately try to circumvent them.

 

These types of headlines make very uncomfortable reading for me. In fact, it reminds me of my happy days working for one of the best independent training providers within the apprenticeship marketplace until subcontracting got the better of them. We should have stayed with our niche, kept our heads down, continued to under-promise and over-deliver…all that we were known for.  But we overstretched and ultimately failed.  My advice to training providers is to ‘stick to the knitting’; do not deviate from your expertise, grow the business and the infrastructure steadily, only employ outstanding people who ‘know their stuff,’ stay close to your learners and employers (ok, and the funding rules) and go the extra mile.

 

Speaking of good practice, having just read the full ESFA Annual Report 2020-21 (yes, I know I’m sad!), I’m also really intrigued to know why the agency hasn’t declared the ethnic (and other diverse) representation on its Board?  This is particularly relevant given the recent Association of Colleges survey highlighting the lack of diversity in FE leadership (reported on in Edition 370 of FE Week) – something I covered in a previous blog.  Disappointingly, in the ESFA Annual Report, under the “Addressing under-representation” section, there are just two (vague) sentences:

  • The department’s diversity and inclusion strategy includes specific targets which have been agreed by Cabinet Office.
  • The agency is working to support representation of BAME and disabled staff at all levels.

 

Hmmmm…

 

Bally

 

For the full report on the ESFA findings go to https://feweek.co.uk/68-live-investigations-into-fe-providers-and-7-more-esfa-accounts-findings/

Share the Post:

You may also like

Related Posts